Alternatives to Shelter Island

Shelter Island, New York, United States

Overview

Cities with a similar vibe but potentially cheaper, safer, or with better weather than Shelter Island.

Upper Brookville

United States

96% Match
Cost
$4,895
Safety
92/100
Temp
11°C
View City

Old Brookville

United States

95% Match
Cost
$4,220
Safety
90/100
Temp
11°C
View City

Sands Point

United States

95% Match
Cost
$5,245
Safety
95/100
Temp
11°C
View City

Darien

United States

95% Match
Cost
$4,440
Safety
92/100
Temp
11°C
View City

Lloyd Harbor

United States

94% Match
Cost
$3,980
Safety
97/100
Temp
11°C
View City

Westhampton Beach

United States

94% Match
Cost
$4,590
Safety
82/100
Temp
12°C
View City

Frequently Asked Questions