Featured Neighborhoods

Islamorada, Florida, United States

Overview

Featured neighborhoods in Islamorada with vibe, safety, and price profiles.

Featured neighborhoods

Featured areas

Lower Matecumbe Key

Local

Known for its beautiful beachfront homes, tranquil vibe, and access to secluded parks and natural attractions. Often less crowded and especially peaceful.

Cost
$$$$$
Safety
5/5
Anne's Beachnature trailsprivate docks

Plantation Key

Family

A quieter, more residential neighborhood at the northern end of Islamorada. It's favored by families and locals for its schools, community parks, and boating options.

Cost
$$$
Safety
5/5
community parksmarinaskayaking

Upper Matecumbe Key

Touristy

Heart of Islamorada with many restaurants, art galleries, marinas, and iconic ocean views. The area is popular with visitors for its walkable atmosphere and access to water activities.

Cost
$$$$
Safety
5/5
art galleriesseafood eateriesfishing charters

Windley Key

Artsy

Home to geological parks and historical sites, Windley Key is great for history buffs and outdoor lovers, offering fossilized coral quarries and serene spots close to the Overseas Highway.

Cost
$$$
Safety
5/5
Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Parkscenic overlookspicnic areas

Frequently Asked Questions